EN FR

Provincial election is a good time for tax cuts

Author: Scott Hennig 2008/01/10
Premier Stelmach's recent musing on whether or not to eliminate Alberta's regressive health care premium was significant for many reasons.

For starters, it's the first time the premier has publicly said eliminating the $1,056 per year per family tax is being considered. Although, to be fair, the premier did tell the Canadian Taxpayers Federation in a survey during his leadership bid that he doesn't like health care premiums (however stopping short of committing to eliminate them).

Second, it makes clear there will be no budget before the election. Premier Stelmach's musing was in relation to the PC Party's upcoming election platform, not the provincial budget, set for release on February 14th. If Premier Stelmach was going to release his fiscal blue-print before calling an election, he would have suggested the budget may contain this tax cut, but he didn't. With the premier out of the province for much of January, expect the election call to follow the throne speech, on February 4th, as was done by Premier Klein in 2001.

Third, and important, it affirms Premier Stelmach, much like Premier Klein before him, is a populist rather than an ideologue. Premier Klein used to say he liked to find out where the parade was headed and then get to the front of it. Premier Stelmach is simply doing the same.

For the cause of eliminating our health care premium tax, this could work in taxpayers favour.

Over the past few years support for eliminating the health care premium has grown significantly. For the longest time only the Canadian Taxpayers Federation and a handful of politicians were advocating the taxes' demise. Now every opposition party in the legislature (Liberal, NDP, and Alberta Alliance) claim they would kill the unpopular tax if they formed government.

Further, support within the PC caucus has grown. During the PC leadership race in the fall of 2006, five of the eight candidates indicated they would eliminate the tax if elected, including the now Finance Minister, Lyle Oberg; the now Health Minister, Dave Hancock; and the now Sustainable Resource Development Minister, Ted Morton.

Support outside the legislature is also strong. In fact, in a November 2006 Ipsos-Reid poll of Albertans, 80 percent supported eliminating the health care premium.

With support growing both inside and outside the legislature to eliminate this so-called health care premium ('so-called' because the money raised doesn't go to health care and it's not a true insurance premium), Premier Stelmach's musing shows he's reading the writing on the wall.

This populist bent from Premier Stelmach means the upcoming provincial election provides the best chance taxpayers have had in years to get this unfair tax eliminated. Premier Stelmach will have little choice but to scrap this tax if Albertans make clear to him that's what they want.

And want it they should.

Albertans haven't seen a significant tax cut from their provincial government since 2001, and in fact swallowed a tax hike in 2002, when lagging oil and gas revenues spurred the Klein government to hike taxes by $641-million (including a 29 percent hike to the health care premium).

The health care premium tax is regressive and in no way reflects Albertans use or risk-of-use of the health care system.

Plus, it would mean $1,056 back in the pockets of most Alberta families each year.

So, when you attend your local election forum, get a phone call from a campaign or run into a candidate in your local coffee shop tell them it's time to eliminate the health care premium tax. You might just get what you ask for.


Alberta Election 2008

Throughout the 2008 Alberta Provincial election, the CTF provided regular updates which are listed below. This included our "Spend-o-meter" which provided an update of the spending promises:
  • All parties respond to CTF questionnaire
  • A present for our next premier
  • Costed out platforms welcomed by CTF
  • PC Party responds to CTF's platform costing request
  • Provincial election spend-o-thon
  • Clearing the air on health care premiums
  • Healthcare Premium Victory
  • Pre-election spending spree tops $1.3 billion
  • Spend-o-Meter (Jan 31, 2008)
  • Spend-o-Meter (Feb 1, 2008)

  • A Note for our Readers:

    Is Canada Off Track?

    Canada has problems. You see them at gas station. You see them at the grocery store. You see them on your taxes.

    Is anyone listening to you to find out where you think Canada’s off track and what you think we could do to make things better?

    You can tell us what you think by filling out the survey

    Join now to get the Taxpayer newsletter

    Franco Terrazzano
    Federal Director at
    Canadian Taxpayers
    Federation

    Join now to get the Taxpayer newsletter

    Hey, it’s Franco.

    Did you know that you can get the inside scoop right from my notebook each week? I’ll share hilarious and infuriating stories the media usually misses with you every week so you can hold politicians accountable.

    You can sign up for the Taxpayer Update Newsletter now

    Looks good!
    Please enter a valid email address

    We take data security and privacy seriously. Your information will be kept safe.

    <